Winnifrith had qualified second-fastest for the final behind Neutral Paralympic Athlete and defending champion Mariia Pavlova.
But Pavlova started the final strongly and maintained her dominance, beating her own world record by 0.77 seconds with a time of 1:26.09 as the Briton set a new personal best of 1:29.69 ahead of Canada’s Tess Routliffe (1:31.38).
“I’m really happy with that swim. Much as I wanted the gold, it’s still a silver medal and a lifetime best,” said the Kent swimmer, who, like her idol Ellie Simmonds, has now won a Paralympic medal aged 13.
“I knew I had to fight for a medal. I tried to catch the other girl as much as possible but today it wasn’t enough.
“Ellie has influenced me so much and I’ve now met her a few times and she has really helped me.”
Winnifrith is Britain’s youngest Paralympic swimming medallist since Scotland’s Abby Kane claimed S13 backstroke silver at Rio 2016, six weeks after her 13th birthday.
Joanne Round, later Joanne Rout, remains Britain’s youngest Paralympic champion after she won two relay golds at the 1988 Seoul Games aged 12.
Shamoon Hafez, BBC Sport football news reporterWith Everton teetering above the drop zone, Moyes' key task will be to ensure the club move into their new stadiu
Jack Draper feels ready to handle the heat in Melbourne after a disrupted build-up to the Australian Open.Expectations for the British number one have soared si
Graham Potter lost his first game as West Ham boss as Aston Villa staged a second-half recovery to knock the Hammers out of the FA Cup with a 2-1 victory.Wycomb
David Moyes could seal his Everton return this weekend as the club’s new owners work to replace the sacked Sean Dyche.According to reports, Moyes has agreed a