Pakistan have not won a home Test match since 2022, with their latest innings-and-47-run embarrassment in Multan a seventh defeat in a winless run of 11.
The hosts appeared in good shape having scored 556 in their first innings against England, only to capitulate with bat and ball on day four before the visitors sealed an emphatic win on Friday.
Pakistan have not only been inconsistent on the field, but their management has also gone through a number of changes over that span, with the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) having had three chairmen, two Test captains and six permanent or temporary head coaches.
In white-ball cricket too, Pakistan were knocked out during the group stage of both the 50-over World Cup last year and T20 World Cup this summer, where they suffered a shock defeat to associate nation the USA.
Assessing the team’s struggles, Sky Sports‘ Nasser Hussain said: “I think it’s a little bit with justification [the criticism].
“Simply because, historically, Pakistan are a mercurial side. They go up and down, win games, lose games, they’ll be out of World Cups and then suddenly in a World Cup final.
“But actually, of late with Pakistan cricket – the two most recent World Cups and now six Tests in a row – they’ve lost.
“It’s all down and it all has a Groundhog Day feel to it. They do OK in the first innings and then second time round, the openers and the top order fail, leaving the middle order to try and dig them out of a hole, like what happened late last night and into today [in Multan].”
Just hours after the conclusion of the first Test, the PCB announced a revamping of its selection committee, including the addition of former international umpire Aleem Dar.
Ex-Test fast bowler Aqib Javed, former Test captain Azhar Ali and analyst Hasan Cheema were also added to the selection committee with voting rights.
The committee already includes Pakistan captain Shan Masood and head coach Jason Gillespie.
The immediate task of the committee is to finalise the squad for the second Test against England – live on Sky Sports Cricket from 5.30am on Tuesday (first ball, 6am).
The PCB said in a statement that committee members held their first meeting in Lahore on Friday, and will meet with the captain and coach in Multan on Saturday before the squad is named for the second Test.
There are also four non-voting members on the selection panel, including assistant coach Azhar Mahmood and Bilal Afazal, an adviser to the PCB chairman.
Dar resigned from the ICC’s elite umpire panel last year but has been supervising in domestic matches, including international games at home. Last month, Dar said he will quit umpiring at the end of the domestic season in 2025.
After his side became the first in Test history to lose by an innings after scoring 500 or more in their first innings, Pakistan captain Masood said the side were “hurt by the result”.
“Where I’d like the team to improve is, no matter what the pitch is like, we must find a way out,” Masood said.
“England showed us the way in this Test, you have to give huge credit to them.
“We’re hurt by the result, hurt as a nation, but the beauty of the game is it always gives you another chance. The quick turnaround [to the second Test, starting Tuesday] might be beneficial to us and we’re looking forward to it.
“I never try to shy away from responsibility. What hurts is that we’re not getting the results that Pakistan cricket deserves. We are all trying hard, we’re going to give it our all and try to turn this around.”
Hussain added: “I don’t blame Shan Masood. You have to look at what goes on behind the scenes in Pakistan cricket.
“Name me one sporting environment, team or a business that does well with constant change behind the scenes, constant changes in chairman of selectors, chief executives, captains, coaches.
“If there’s constant changes, there’s constant messages that are coming in that are different, and that consistency that was always lacking in Pakistan cricket goes even more out of the window.
“They have structural issues in their cricket, and that’s the world game’s fault as well. It’s not their fault.
“We talk about the big three [Australia, England and India] and the finances they get, with other sides falling behind. Pakistan is one of those sides that’s falling behind.”
One of the big concerns facing Pakistan ahead of the second Test is the form of star batter Babar Azam.
The 29-year-old former Test captain managed scores of just 30 and five in the first Test, making it now nine Tests without a half-century on extremely batting-friendly, flat pitches.
Their top seam bowlers, Shaheen Afridi (1-120) and Naseem Shah (2-157) were also below par, while frontline spinner Abrar Ahmed (0-174) went wicketless through his 35 overs before leaving the game to illness.
“They do have problems,” Hussain said. “Their best player – a world-class player – Babar Azam is horrendously out of form.
“It’s nine Test matches without a half century – on these pitches!
“Maybe that’s psychological, with everything that he’s been through, giving up the white-ball captaincy?
“In this part of the world, if you are Babar Azam and you go two games without a half century or a hundred, the pressure builds, let alone eight, nine Test matches. The pressure is on him, definitely.”
Hussain added: “Spin hasn’t seemed to be much of a threat. Where are they with their spinners?
“Historically, we would have played against Abdul Qadir, Saqlain Mushtaq, Mushtaq Ahmed. They’ve always produced great mystery spinners.
“And express pace: you wouldn’t say any of their three seamers that they are playing at the moment are express pace.
“That’s a dangerous combination. You have a top order that’s failing in the second innings and you’re not sure what pitch to prepare that suits your bowling attack.”
First Test: Multan – October 7-11 – England won by an innings and 47 runs
Second Test: Multan – October 15-19
Third Test: Rawalpindi – October 24-28
Every match from the 2024 Women’s T20 World Cup is also live on Sky Sports from October 3-20 with Australia aiming for a third straight title and seventh overall, and England seeking to triumph for the first time since the inaugural edition in 2009.
Watch day one of the second Test between Pakistan and England in Multan, live on Sky Sports Cricket and Main Event from 5.30am on Tuesday, ahead of play starting from 6am. Stream with NOW
Fabio Wardley’s huge rematch with Frazer Clarke is on the epic Artur Beterbiev vs Dmitry Bivol bill on Saturday October 12 live on Sky Sports Box Office. Book Wardley v Clarke 2 and Beterbiev v Bivol now!
London [UK], : Former cricketer Courtney Winfield-Hill will join the England Women coaching set-up as an assistant coach for the upcoming tour to South Afric
Former cricketer and rugby league player Courtney Winfield-Hill has been named as an assistant coach for England Women’s tour of
Australian-born Courtney Winfield-Hill will join England's coaching team this winter for the tour of South Africa and Women's Ashes down under.Winfield-Hill pla
Sign up to our free sport newsletter for all the latest news on everything from cycling to boxingSign up to our free sport email for all the latest newsSign up